{
  "template": "corridor-anomaly-watch",
  "templateName": "Trade anomaly page",
  "source": "api",
  "publisher": {
    "name": "Yugalinks",
    "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com",
    "linkedin": "https://in.linkedin.com/company/yugalinks",
    "logo": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/yugalinks-logo-v3-dark-mode.webp"
  },
  "seo": {
    "title": "Madagascar to South Africa trade anomaly | HS 330210 | Yugalinks",
    "description": "Reported trade anomaly for Madagascar to South Africa in odoriferous substances and mixtures (HS 330210), with anomaly severity, market value, history,...",
    "canonical": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/mdg-zaf-330210",
    "robots": "index, follow"
  },
  "breadcrumbs": [
    {
      "name": "Home",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/"
    },
    {
      "name": "Trade data",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/"
    },
    {
      "name": "Trade anomalies",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/"
    },
    {
      "name": "MDG-ZAF HS 330210",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/mdg-zaf-330210"
    }
  ],
  "sections": [
    "overview",
    "history",
    "context",
    "related-movements",
    "faq",
    "data-source"
  ],
  "anomaly": {
    "year": 2024,
    "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
    "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
    "hs_code": "330210",
    "market_imports_usd": 529843446.67665726,
    "momentum_yoy_pct": 388.0958945945131,
    "anomaly_z_score": 2.2660059971554283,
    "anomaly_type": "spike",
    "anomaly_severity": "56.65014992888571",
    "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
    "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0
  },
  "opportunity": {
    "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
    "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
    "hs_code": "330210",
    "hs_description": "Odoriferous substances and mixtures: of a kind used in the food or drink industries",
    "hs_chapter": "33",
    "hs_heading": "3302",
    "price_range_label": "High price range",
    "trade_type_label": "One-way trade",
    "substitution_elasticity": -0.19951069,
    "buyer_imports_latest_usd": 529843446.67665714,
    "buyer_imports_avg_usd": 283892967.98306966,
    "buyer_imports_peak_usd": 529843446.67665714,
    "buyer_cagr_full_pct": 12.5669,
    "buyer_yoy_avg_pct": 25.0138,
    "buyer_yoy_latest_pct": 16.8121,
    "buyer_trend_consistency_pct": 58.3333,
    "buyer_imports_proj_3y_usd": 755753124.76,
    "buyer_imports_proj_5y_usd": 957638375.06,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_latest": 419946.428126,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_latest": 6994,
    "buyer_population_latest": 60041.996,
    "buyer_investment_rate": 19.8,
    "buyer_savings_rate": 19.18,
    "buyer_edu_secondary": 86.3,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_2030_proj": 433176.51,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_2030_proj": 6796.3,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_growth_pct": -2.83,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_growth_pct": 3.15,
    "buyer_pop_growth_pct": 6.15,
    "exports_latest_usd": 67.12046677819646,
    "exports_avg_usd": 5079.978941469481,
    "exports_peak_usd": 21461.013019704715,
    "share_latest_pct": 0.000012667980928932292,
    "share_avg_pct": 0.001973631833446762,
    "share_peak_pct": 0.007893702267073902,
    "share_change_1y_pp": 0.000009636253604370003,
    "share_trend_pp_per_yr": -0.000261,
    "cagr_full_pct": -16.7345,
    "yoy_avg_pct": 61.6216,
    "yoy_latest_pct": 388.0959,
    "trend_consistency_pct": 66.6667,
    "exports_proj_3y_usd": 38.75,
    "exports_proj_5y_usd": 26.86,
    "your_share_gap_pp": 70.7879,
    "addressable_proj_3y_usd": 534981740.43,
    "addressable_proj_5y_usd": 677892062.65,
    "peer_best_share_pct": 70.78790925820334,
    "peer_top_exporter": "SWZ",
    "num_suppliers_latest": 86,
    "buyer_herfindahl_index": 5153.78,
    "distance_km": 3326.97314453125,
    "shares_official_language": 0,
    "common_spoken_language_score": 0,
    "has_wto_reported_fta": 1,
    "buyer_is_eu_member": 0,
    "buyer_biz_entry_days": 40,
    "shared_legal_system": 0,
    "shared_religion": 0,
    "shares_land_border": 0,
    "buyer_is_wto_member": 1,
    "lane_volatility_cv": 1.3028413310613123,
    "lane_max_drawdown_pct": 99.96262176626543,
    "signal_flag": "Declining",
    "lane_data_years": 10,
    "lane_last_year": 2024
  },
  "lane": {
    "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
    "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
    "hs_code": "330210"
  },
  "routeHistory": [
    {
      "year": 2004,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 2615.5166147870073,
      "yoy_growth_pct": null,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null
    },
    {
      "year": 2006,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 3040.639744269295,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 16.253887552417922,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null
    },
    {
      "year": 2016,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 3450.664354953402,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 13.484813893420998,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null
    },
    {
      "year": 2017,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 8278.049996573498,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 139.89728194486437,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 46.821679369861144
    },
    {
      "year": 2018,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 21461.013019704715,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 159.2520343388599,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 91.82052857352775
    },
    {
      "year": 2019,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 11789.390969993912,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -45.06600895694287,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 50.6131474234913
    },
    {
      "year": 2021,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 75.6210082557973,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -99.3585673047211,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -79.09557917810656
    },
    {
      "year": 2022,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 8.021747608313714,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -89.3921705180402,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -92.79656582712991
    },
    {
      "year": 2023,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 13.751491770681039,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 71.42762951590544,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -89.47344781926763
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "hs_code": "330210",
      "export_value_usd": 67.12046677819646,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 388.0958945945131,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -3.89687685974055
    }
  ],
  "corridorHistory": [
    {
      "year": 2000,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 3609381.172701541,
      "yoy_growth_pct": null,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2001,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 8467055.741612999,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 134.58469295653796,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2002,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 3029230.9897275316,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -64.22332529547687,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2003,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 10379986.526332058,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 242.66077963456,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 42.207121943313574,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2004,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 1958239.7099608076,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -81.13446770867068,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -38.617513345682575,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2005,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 2703944.0232782904,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 38.080338659479416,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -3.7157832545655856,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2006,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 2827783.683377805,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 4.5799638984157065,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -35.173914429798415,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2007,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 5916125.580756542,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 109.214220151723,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 44.563008252828105,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2008,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 13803673.721375335,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 133.32286532717833,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 72.1864595220324,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2009,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 16399232.173923505,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 18.80338890167248,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 79.66319148160828,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2010,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 19333058.183919754,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 17.89002057462994,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 48.39561156740386,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2011,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 36734996.06232458,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 90.01130453783492,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 38.57826003824989,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2012,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 56808971.473354936,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 54.64537243170751,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 51.30889883196639,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2013,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 94163700.98769657,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 65.75498296402374,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 69.50960838425387,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2014,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 130891650.29344916,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 39.00436040693798,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 52.73690356767451,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2015,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 118966834.11251216,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -9.110448339678257,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 27.939012029743072,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2016,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 101170002.13503361,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -14.959490273270026,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 2.421094660424772,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2017,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 99387057.16819799,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -1.7623257183052021,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -8.769659452065925,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2018,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 116336667.94507931,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 17.054142923455906,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.7424452212862698,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2019,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 100167855.87874356,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -13.898293935983098,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.3312818384848426,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2020,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 73555013.61532395,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -26.568245900796082,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -9.546061189471821,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2021,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 113758379.74255061,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 54.657546985826365,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.7442689728483165,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2022,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 155187374.52844718,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 36.418411443320075,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 15.711361239019329,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2023,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 130755674.04399738,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -15.743355771491107,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 21.138656994212003,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ZAF",
      "export_value_usd": 138305974.53524292,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 5.774357821523646,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 6.7298373991458105,
      "distance_km": 2158,
      "capital_distance_km": 2129,
      "shares_land_border": 0,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 1,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_is_eu": 0,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 419946.428126,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 6994.21165355662,
      "importer_population": 60041.996,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 40,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 0.2,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 14637.400396000001,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 514.9058436503402,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.239,
      "scientific_collaboration": 3915,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 10.787210211494951,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 11.33147539878788,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0.000005088478787878788,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 11.331470310309093
    }
  ],
  "relatedAnomalies": [
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "CHE",
      "hs_code": "300490",
      "market_imports_usd": 41005734977.72727,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 190549.9620039449,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.6457357341319176,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "66.14339335329794",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "Switzerland"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "NLD",
      "hs_code": "851762",
      "market_imports_usd": 10689956470.080564,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 8705.663216893558,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.051004561976064,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "76.27511404940161",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "NLD"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "NLD",
      "hs_code": "847130",
      "market_imports_usd": 8866258376.020266,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 5396.584502495821,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.241576268148388,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "81.0394067037097",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "NLD"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "USA",
      "hs_code": "847170",
      "market_imports_usd": 8430026073.960695,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 11344.214737217386,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.172903280765478,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "54.322582019136945",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "USA, Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "ESP",
      "hs_code": "271019",
      "market_imports_usd": 8083826798.971083,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 2298.248533807806,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.741368146633268,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "93.53420366583171",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "Spain"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "POL",
      "hs_code": "271019",
      "market_imports_usd": 5610472194.533947,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 2255.4932091067526,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.328099605283216,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "83.2024901320804",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "Poland"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "MEX",
      "hs_code": "847170",
      "market_imports_usd": 5284442339.362536,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 2893.175208123048,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.286568592936172,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "57.1642148234043",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "Mexico"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "MDG",
      "importer_iso3": "FRA",
      "hs_code": "850760",
      "market_imports_usd": 3154424902.4220805,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 18695.686961611013,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.719873971996211,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "92.99684929990526",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "Madagascar",
      "importer_name": "France"
    }
  ],
  "links": {
    "html": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/mdg-zaf-330210",
    "markdown": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/mdg-zaf-330210/index.md",
    "json": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/mdg-zaf-330210/index.json",
    "jsonLd": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/mdg-zaf-330210/index.ld.json",
    "dataSources": "https://www.yugalinks.com/data-sources",
    "methodology": "https://www.yugalinks.com/methodology"
  },
  "methodology": {
    "summary": "Reported trade observations and calculated indicators are shown separately. An unusual movement is a research prompt, not a causal conclusion or commercial forecast.",
    "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/methodology"
  },
  "generatedAt": "2026-09-03T09:10:40.015Z",
  "artifactContract": {
    "html": "Full visual page",
    "markdown": "Readable page content and evidence",
    "json": "Complete page data",
    "jsonLd": "Page metadata, FAQ, and provenance"
  }
}