{ "template": "corridor-anomaly-watch", "templateName": "Trade anomaly page", "source": "api", "publisher": { "name": "Yugalinks", "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com", "linkedin": "https://in.linkedin.com/company/yugalinks", "logo": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/yugalinks-logo-v3-dark-mode.webp" }, "seo": { "title": "India to Belgium trade anomaly | HS 090412 | Yugalinks", "description": "Reported trade anomaly for India to Belgium in spices (HS 090412), with anomaly severity, market value, history, and context.", "canonical": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/ind-bel-090412", "robots": "index, follow" }, "breadcrumbs": [ { "name": "Home", "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/" }, { "name": "Trade data", "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/" }, { "name": "Trade anomalies", "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/" }, { "name": "IND-BEL HS 090412", "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/ind-bel-090412" } ], "sections": [ "overview", "history", "context", "related-movements", "faq", "data-source" ], "anomaly": { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "market_imports_usd": 9181295.891842552, "momentum_yoy_pct": 6622.019780347505, "anomaly_z_score": 3.764178386602909, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "94.10445966507272", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0 }, "opportunity": { "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "hs_description": "Spices: pepper (of the genus piper), crushed or ground", "hs_chapter": "09", "hs_heading": "0904", "price_range_label": "Low price range", "trade_type_label": "One-way trade", "substitution_elasticity": -6.5055566, "buyer_imports_latest_usd": 9181295.891842553, "buyer_imports_avg_usd": 7311315.8938306505, "buyer_imports_peak_usd": 12460919.016858412, "buyer_cagr_full_pct": 4.6617, "buyer_yoy_avg_pct": 7.2927, "buyer_yoy_latest_pct": -0.0184, "buyer_trend_consistency_pct": 48, "buyer_imports_proj_3y_usd": 10526084.36, "buyer_imports_proj_5y_usd": 11530339.31, "buyer_gdp_mn_latest": 599879.025378, "buyer_gdp_pc_latest": 51768, "buyer_population_latest": 11587.882, "buyer_investment_rate": 23.69, "buyer_savings_rate": 24.85, "buyer_edu_secondary": 92.2, "buyer_gdp_mn_2030_proj": 621018.19, "buyer_gdp_pc_2030_proj": 52803.09, "buyer_gdp_pc_growth_pct": 2, "buyer_gdp_mn_growth_pct": 3.52, "buyer_pop_growth_pct": 1.49, "exports_latest_usd": 11416.148000814677, "exports_avg_usd": 301134.280614835, "exports_peak_usd": 1414631.026702566, "share_latest_pct": 0.12434135807514662, "share_avg_pct": 4.36232689843507, "share_peak_pct": 18.0633066791246, "share_change_1y_pp": 0.12249193692342196, "share_trend_pp_per_yr": -0.016182, "cagr_full_pct": -1.2272, "yoy_avg_pct": 592.6103, "yoy_latest_pct": 6622.0198, "trend_consistency_pct": 52, "exports_proj_3y_usd": 11000.98, "exports_proj_5y_usd": 10732.62, "your_share_gap_pp": 61.6194, "addressable_proj_3y_usd": 6486111.09, "addressable_proj_5y_usd": 7104927.07, "peer_best_share_pct": 61.74375147545227, "peer_top_exporter": "NLD", "num_suppliers_latest": 51, "buyer_herfindahl_index": 4318.6, "distance_km": 6419.5986328125, "shares_official_language": 0, "common_spoken_language_score": null, "has_wto_reported_fta": 0, "buyer_is_eu_member": 1, "buyer_biz_entry_days": 5, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shares_land_border": 0, "buyer_is_wto_member": 1, "lane_volatility_cv": 1.2020664890516064, "lane_max_drawdown_pct": 99.98799460026, "signal_flag": "Stable", "lane_data_years": 26, "lane_last_year": 2024 }, "lane": { "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412" }, "routeHistory": [ { "year": 1999, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 15544.937591252512, "yoy_growth_pct": null, "cagr_3y_pct": null }, { "year": 2000, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 120720.41442617027, "yoy_growth_pct": 676.5898944110421, "cagr_3y_pct": null }, { "year": 2001, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 26331.063631182966, "yoy_growth_pct": -78.18839194982517, "cagr_3y_pct": null }, { "year": 2002, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 41328.38458194313, "yoy_growth_pct": 56.95676088450661, "cagr_3y_pct": 38.53297127318414 }, { "year": 2003, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 100090.1263749546, "yoy_growth_pct": 142.18252754714538, "cagr_3y_pct": -6.055756552831548 }, { "year": 2004, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 286143.16639818356, "yoy_growth_pct": 185.88550815316455, "cagr_3y_pct": 121.49894330190443 }, { "year": 2005, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 349742.91125810024, "yoy_growth_pct": 22.226546822863558, "cagr_3y_pct": 103.7824738857295 }, { "year": 2006, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 518027.1607072354, "yoy_growth_pct": 48.11655762908265, "cagr_3y_pct": 72.9764969695453 }, { "year": 2007, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 952808.4836652307, "yoy_growth_pct": 83.93021755160697, "cagr_3y_pct": 49.327827080461795 }, { "year": 2008, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 1414631.026702566, "yoy_growth_pct": 48.469608631192315, "cagr_3y_pct": 59.33019443062992 }, { "year": 2009, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 834278.7662788832, "yoy_growth_pct": -41.02499163873529, "cagr_3y_pct": 17.215817226575126 }, { "year": 2010, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 454180.2286651335, "yoy_growth_pct": -45.560135649753576, "cagr_3y_pct": -21.883842974315606 }, { "year": 2011, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 585342.5870658314, "yoy_growth_pct": 28.87892297429877, "cagr_3y_pct": -25.48295098463419 }, { "year": 2012, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 942593.1069129321, "yoy_growth_pct": 61.032723014039306, "cagr_3y_pct": 4.152817567095046 }, { "year": 2013, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 307645.4556325344, "yoy_growth_pct": -67.3617965826105, "cagr_3y_pct": -12.177170226824662 }, { "year": 2014, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 173227.77349412747, "yoy_growth_pct": -43.69239970148022, "cagr_3y_pct": -33.35987542821418 }, { "year": 2015, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 116223.25219629315, "yoy_growth_pct": -32.90726431911729, "cagr_3y_pct": -50.227484774768286 }, { "year": 2016, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 1525.9025030474968, "yoy_growth_pct": -98.68709361146567, "cagr_3y_pct": -82.94603265586986 }, { "year": 2017, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 60295.140409892265, "yoy_growth_pct": 3851.441215246205, "cagr_3y_pct": -29.65688507008223 }, { "year": 2018, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 5823.0007770755265, "yoy_growth_pct": -90.34250399370464, "cagr_3y_pct": -63.134685655907276 }, { "year": 2019, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 220999.93561951513, "yoy_growth_pct": 3695.2929096208613, "cagr_3y_pct": 425.1561477346522 }, { "year": 2020, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 129022.56137436217, "yoy_growth_pct": -41.61873350203411, "cagr_3y_pct": 28.862865019565874 }, { "year": 2021, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 111261.20482518253, "yoy_growth_pct": -13.766085837998999, "cagr_3y_pct": 167.34104223008583 }, { "year": 2022, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 50118.724783662154, "yoy_growth_pct": -54.95399779068505, "cagr_3y_pct": -39.01786546909395 }, { "year": 2023, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 169.83210960180338, "yoy_growth_pct": -99.66114040144699, "cagr_3y_pct": -89.04065206603426 }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "hs_code": "090412", "export_value_usd": 11416.148000814677, "yoy_growth_pct": 6622.019780347505, "cagr_3y_pct": -53.18425445411123 } ], "corridorHistory": [ { "year": 1999, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 1386184924.8279154, "yoy_growth_pct": null, "cagr_3y_pct": null, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2000, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 1512175660.0963666, "yoy_growth_pct": 9.089027950876893, "cagr_3y_pct": null, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2001, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 1453616616.884813, "yoy_growth_pct": -3.8725026964011477, "cagr_3y_pct": null, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2002, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 1630652144.4576406, "yoy_growth_pct": 12.178969717078857, "cagr_3y_pct": 5.563403704188374, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2003, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 1874365803.056445, "yoy_growth_pct": 14.945778560262092, "cagr_3y_pct": 7.419725006857147, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2004, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 2501123409.358785, "yoy_growth_pct": 33.438382480106846, "cagr_3y_pct": 19.828948216431975, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2005, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 2867418725.3451676, "yoy_growth_pct": 14.645231603357377, "cagr_3y_pct": 20.700739348514084, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2006, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 3475556438.028866, "yoy_growth_pct": 21.208542279101316, "cagr_3y_pct": 22.854197015698684, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2007, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4177011218.8318872, "yoy_growth_pct": 20.182517341046147, "cagr_3y_pct": 18.64337896124557, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2008, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 5067446141.622737, "yoy_growth_pct": 21.317513316132832, "cagr_3y_pct": 20.901774420387653, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2009, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 3599688255.559058, "yoy_growth_pct": -28.964449646694458, "cagr_3y_pct": 1.17662351643133, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2010, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4262149484.917886, "yoy_growth_pct": 18.403294461285014, "cagr_3y_pct": 0.6748548043583158, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2011, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 6505115869.952082, "yoy_growth_pct": 52.62523975217657, "cagr_3y_pct": 8.68141855305733, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2012, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 5026680643.493565, "yoy_growth_pct": -22.727269675357952, "cagr_3y_pct": 11.773487322402776, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2013, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 5373181496.489849, "yoy_growth_pct": 6.893233876808713, "cagr_3y_pct": 8.027488063811461, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2014, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4973501520.51699, "yoy_growth_pct": -7.438423143419948, "cagr_3y_pct": -8.560100626976153, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2015, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4190809330.79526, "yoy_growth_pct": -15.737246414682303, "cagr_3y_pct": -5.88210559983774, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2016, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4318397140.534442, "yoy_growth_pct": 3.044467062761136, "cagr_3y_pct": -7.02553463199661, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2017, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4824168377.472978, "yoy_growth_pct": 11.71201305667644, "cagr_3y_pct": -1.011046227355128, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2018, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 5253460119.624873, "yoy_growth_pct": 8.898771944953744, "cagr_3y_pct": 7.824101005266337, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2019, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 4625350335.62055, "yoy_growth_pct": -11.956115963609404, "cagr_3y_pct": 2.3153241294880944, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2020, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 3575344013.7747226, "yoy_growth_pct": -22.701119821336857, "cagr_3y_pct": -9.503497997011179, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2021, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 6775761403.402532, "yoy_growth_pct": 89.51355106802494, "cagr_3y_pct": 8.852286226793149, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2022, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 7396672170.173545, "yoy_growth_pct": 9.163704708657772, "cagr_3y_pct": 16.940221629271758, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2023, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 6073383909.906634, "yoy_growth_pct": -17.89031918438887, "cagr_3y_pct": 19.317542457073912, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "BEL", "export_value_usd": 5056289680.886462, "yoy_growth_pct": -16.746746856577488, "cagr_3y_pct": -9.296381252792374, "distance_km": 6422, "capital_distance_km": 6422, "shares_land_border": 0, "shares_official_language": 0, "shares_ethnic_language": 0, "shared_religion": 0, "shared_legal_system": 0, "shared_colonial_history": 0, "has_fta": 0, "rta_coverage_ratio": null, "exporter_is_wto": 1, "importer_is_wto": 1, "exporter_is_eu": 0, "importer_is_eu": 1, "importer_gdp_million_usd": 599879.0253780001, "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 51767.78857240694, "importer_population": 11587.882, "importer_biz_entry_days": 5, "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 5.3, "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 3173397.5908170003, "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 2277.434305882774, "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.01700455832185727, "scientific_collaboration": 0.014030664250461037, "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 1.9243141578797984, "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 5.920413126868687, "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 1.6369810062462136, "tariff_advantage_pp": 4.283432120622474 } ], "relatedAnomalies": [ { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "HKG", "hs_code": "710812", "market_imports_usd": 41743878490.2161, "momentum_yoy_pct": 881312.983340332, "anomaly_z_score": 3.9915664466015692, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "99.78916116503923", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "China, Hong Kong SAR" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "CHN", "hs_code": "848620", "market_imports_usd": 34193009725.873837, "momentum_yoy_pct": 32779.194222158236, "anomaly_z_score": 3.1207423798020977, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "78.01855949505244", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "CHN" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "USA", "hs_code": "847330", "market_imports_usd": 32437253404.79868, "momentum_yoy_pct": -99.48236316295385, "anomaly_z_score": -2.384467431425413, "anomaly_type": "drop", "anomaly_severity": "59.61168578563532", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "USA, Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "USA", "hs_code": "710812", "market_imports_usd": 21528311466.103046, "momentum_yoy_pct": 471614.5912097896, "anomaly_z_score": 3.681367488809768, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "92.0341872202442", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "USA, Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "KOR", "hs_code": "854239", "market_imports_usd": 15909752628.038187, "momentum_yoy_pct": 963.6188028225067, "anomaly_z_score": 4.1058251398481795, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "100", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "KOR" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "THA", "hs_code": "710812", "market_imports_usd": 14067731674.616661, "momentum_yoy_pct": 85725.07907115985, "anomaly_z_score": 3.8673020105047353, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "96.68255026261838", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "Thailand" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "HKG", "hs_code": "847330", "market_imports_usd": 11747584627.6957, "momentum_yoy_pct": 314.3558382817881, "anomaly_z_score": 3.295197390936888, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "82.3799347734222", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "China, Hong Kong SAR" }, { "year": 2024, "exporter_iso3": "IND", "importer_iso3": "TWN", "hs_code": "848620", "market_imports_usd": 10604578489.389444, "momentum_yoy_pct": 67816.17736874423, "anomaly_z_score": 2.998089349459092, "anomaly_type": "spike", "anomaly_severity": "74.9522337364773", "new_corridor_signal_type": "", "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0, "exporter_name": "India", "importer_name": "Taiwan" } ], "links": { "html": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/ind-bel-090412", "markdown": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/ind-bel-090412/index.md", "json": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/ind-bel-090412/index.json", "jsonLd": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/ind-bel-090412/index.ld.json", "dataSources": "https://www.yugalinks.com/data-sources", "methodology": "https://www.yugalinks.com/methodology" }, "methodology": { "summary": "Reported trade observations and calculated indicators are shown separately. An unusual movement is a research prompt, not a causal conclusion or commercial forecast.", "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/methodology" }, "generatedAt": "2026-09-03T09:34:38.301Z", "artifactContract": { "html": "Full visual page", "markdown": "Readable page content and evidence", "json": "Complete page data", "jsonLd": "Page metadata, FAQ, and provenance" } }