{
  "template": "corridor-anomaly-watch",
  "templateName": "Trade anomaly page",
  "source": "api",
  "publisher": {
    "name": "Yugalinks",
    "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com",
    "linkedin": "https://in.linkedin.com/company/yugalinks",
    "logo": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/yugalinks-logo-v3-dark-mode.webp"
  },
  "seo": {
    "title": "France to Germany trade anomaly | HS 180400 | Yugalinks",
    "description": "Reported trade anomaly for France to Germany in cocoa (HS 180400), with anomaly severity, market value, history, and context.",
    "canonical": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/fra-deu-180400",
    "robots": "index, follow"
  },
  "breadcrumbs": [
    {
      "name": "Home",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/"
    },
    {
      "name": "Trade data",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/"
    },
    {
      "name": "Trade anomalies",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/"
    },
    {
      "name": "FRA-DEU HS 180400",
      "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/fra-deu-180400"
    }
  ],
  "sections": [
    "overview",
    "history",
    "context",
    "related-movements",
    "faq",
    "data-source"
  ],
  "anomaly": {
    "year": 2024,
    "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
    "importer_iso3": "DEU",
    "hs_code": "180400",
    "market_imports_usd": 1876309182.8480072,
    "momentum_yoy_pct": 353.2793569471269,
    "anomaly_z_score": 4.899526972239256,
    "anomaly_type": "spike",
    "anomaly_severity": "100",
    "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
    "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0
  },
  "opportunity": {
    "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
    "importer_iso3": "DEU",
    "hs_code": "180400",
    "hs_description": "Cocoa: butter, fat and oil",
    "hs_chapter": "18",
    "hs_heading": "1804",
    "price_range_label": "Medium price range",
    "trade_type_label": "One-way trade",
    "substitution_elasticity": -19.937757,
    "buyer_imports_latest_usd": 1876309182.8480077,
    "buyer_imports_avg_usd": 574440628.1869195,
    "buyer_imports_peak_usd": 1876309182.8480077,
    "buyer_cagr_full_pct": 6.8497,
    "buyer_yoy_avg_pct": 9.7719,
    "buyer_yoy_latest_pct": 116.388,
    "buyer_trend_consistency_pct": 55.1724,
    "buyer_imports_proj_3y_usd": 2288885629.25,
    "buyer_imports_proj_5y_usd": 2613187375.23,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_latest": 4223116.205969,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_latest": 50802,
    "buyer_population_latest": 83129.288,
    "buyer_investment_rate": 22.08,
    "buyer_savings_rate": 27.68,
    "buyer_edu_secondary": 95.9,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_2030_proj": 4391279.94,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_2030_proj": 53142.97,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_growth_pct": 4.61,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_growth_pct": 3.98,
    "buyer_pop_growth_pct": -0.6,
    "exports_latest_usd": 180691971.36551902,
    "exports_avg_usd": 45834040.26618771,
    "exports_peak_usd": 180691971.36551902,
    "share_latest_pct": 9.630181049972308,
    "share_avg_pct": 9.506970184161434,
    "share_peak_pct": 18.335043111161685,
    "share_change_1y_pp": 5.032892702215902,
    "share_trend_pp_per_yr": -0.029229,
    "cagr_full_pct": 6.5393,
    "yoy_avg_pct": 16.8154,
    "yoy_latest_pct": 353.2794,
    "trend_consistency_pct": 58.6207,
    "exports_proj_3y_usd": 218508609.2,
    "exports_proj_5y_usd": 248020940.8,
    "your_share_gap_pp": 42.5106,
    "addressable_proj_3y_usd": 973019973.99,
    "addressable_proj_5y_usd": 1110882727.99,
    "peer_best_share_pct": 52.14082297806315,
    "peer_top_exporter": "NLD",
    "num_suppliers_latest": 78,
    "buyer_herfindahl_index": 3073.19,
    "distance_km": 439.8984375,
    "shares_official_language": 0,
    "common_spoken_language_score": 0.3893837034702301,
    "has_wto_reported_fta": 1,
    "buyer_is_eu_member": 1,
    "buyer_biz_entry_days": 8,
    "shared_legal_system": 0,
    "shared_religion": 0,
    "shares_land_border": 1,
    "buyer_is_wto_member": 1,
    "lane_volatility_cv": 0.6013787232854366,
    "lane_max_drawdown_pct": 67.34071613905189,
    "signal_flag": "Growing",
    "lane_data_years": 30,
    "lane_last_year": 2024
  },
  "lane": {
    "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
    "importer_iso3": "DEU",
    "hs_code": "180400",
    "hs_description": "Cocoa: butter, fat and oil",
    "hs_chapter": "18",
    "hs_heading": "1804",
    "price_range_label": "Medium price range",
    "trade_type_label": "One-way trade",
    "substitution_elasticity": -19.937757,
    "buyer_imports_latest_usd": 1876309182.8480077,
    "buyer_imports_avg_usd": 574440628.1869195,
    "buyer_imports_peak_usd": 1876309182.8480077,
    "buyer_cagr_full_pct": 6.8497,
    "buyer_yoy_avg_pct": 9.7719,
    "buyer_yoy_latest_pct": 116.388,
    "buyer_trend_consistency_pct": 55.1724,
    "buyer_imports_proj_3y_usd": 2288885629.25,
    "buyer_imports_proj_5y_usd": 2613187375.23,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_latest": 4223116.205969,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_latest": 50802,
    "buyer_population_latest": 83129.288,
    "buyer_investment_rate": 22.08,
    "buyer_savings_rate": 27.68,
    "buyer_edu_secondary": 95.9,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_2030_proj": 4391279.94,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_2030_proj": 53142.97,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_growth_pct": 4.61,
    "buyer_gdp_mn_growth_pct": 3.98,
    "buyer_pop_growth_pct": -0.6,
    "exports_latest_usd": 180691971.36551902,
    "exports_avg_usd": 45834040.26618771,
    "exports_peak_usd": 180691971.36551902,
    "share_latest_pct": 9.630181049972308,
    "share_avg_pct": 9.506970184161434,
    "share_peak_pct": 18.335043111161685,
    "share_change_1y_pp": 5.032892702215902,
    "share_trend_pp_per_yr": -0.029229,
    "cagr_full_pct": 6.5393,
    "yoy_avg_pct": 16.8154,
    "yoy_latest_pct": 353.2794,
    "trend_consistency_pct": 58.6207,
    "exports_proj_3y_usd": 218508609.2,
    "exports_proj_5y_usd": 248020940.8,
    "your_share_gap_pp": 42.5106,
    "addressable_proj_3y_usd": 973019973.99,
    "addressable_proj_5y_usd": 1110882727.99,
    "peer_best_share_pct": 52.14082297806315,
    "peer_top_exporter": "NLD",
    "num_suppliers_latest": 78,
    "buyer_herfindahl_index": 3073.19,
    "distance_km": 439.8984375,
    "shares_official_language": 0,
    "common_spoken_language_score": 0.3893837034702301,
    "has_wto_reported_fta": 1,
    "buyer_is_eu_member": 1,
    "buyer_biz_entry_days": 8,
    "shared_legal_system": 0,
    "shared_religion": 0,
    "shares_land_border": 1,
    "buyer_is_wto_member": 1,
    "lane_volatility_cv": 0.6013787232854366,
    "lane_max_drawdown_pct": 67.34071613905189,
    "signal_flag": "Growing",
    "lane_data_years": 30,
    "lane_last_year": 2024,
    "access_data_year": 2024,
    "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
    "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
    "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
    "tariff_advantage_pp": 0,
    "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
    "buyer_macro_latest_year": 2024,
    "buyer_gdp_5y_cagr_pct": 3.422772294996279,
    "buyer_gdp_pc_5y_cagr_pct": 3.3176380750794765,
    "buyer_population_5y_cagr_pct": 0.10175824948728263,
    "buyer_investment_5y_avg_pct": 22.237999999999996,
    "buyer_savings_5y_avg_pct": 27.802,
    "current_below_peak_usd": 0,
    "current_below_peak_pct": 0,
    "latest_vs_historical_avg_pct": 294.23094781984014,
    "share_change_all_pp": -0.87687,
    "volatility_label": "Variable",
    "drawdown_label": "Recovered after a severe historical decline",
    "competition_label": "Concentrated buyer market",
    "demand_label": "Buyer demand stable or growing",
    "access_label": "Reported FTA available",
    "macro_resilience_label": "Buyer macro trend resilient",
    "risk_driver_labels": [
      "concentrated_buyer_market",
      "dominant_supplier"
    ],
    "risk_driver_count": 2,
    "attention_level": "High attention",
    "primary_risk_reason": "The buyer market is concentrated among relatively few suppliers"
  },
  "routeHistory": [
    {
      "year": 1995,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 28784042.572034158,
      "yoy_growth_pct": null,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null
    },
    {
      "year": 1996,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 38313576.29475824,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 33.10700260005428,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null
    },
    {
      "year": 1997,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 26902603.52967575,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -29.7831052817788,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null
    },
    {
      "year": 1998,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 36959829.50561603,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 37.383838946466085,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 8.690784557472897
    },
    {
      "year": 1999,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 45491018.88489772,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 23.082328824015196,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 5.890660513577761
    },
    {
      "year": 2000,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 35750282.39598433,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -21.412438603671625,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 9.941516139846861
    },
    {
      "year": 2001,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 26009369.311005704,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -27.247094098682645,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -11.052593950752065
    },
    {
      "year": 2002,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 34197241.44590515,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 31.480471660013663,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -9.073919581642787
    },
    {
      "year": 2003,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 44330937.119875796,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 29.633079293839003,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 7.434181249697391
    },
    {
      "year": 2004,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 35247140.57751601,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -20.490874167167238,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 10.661874667483296
    },
    {
      "year": 2005,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 35594646.80173121,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 0.9859132358579714,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 1.3439601843121984
    },
    {
      "year": 2006,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 45671801.79720993,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 28.310872282594502,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 0.9982257225771729
    },
    {
      "year": 2007,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 48400587.19911,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 5.974770634222648,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 11.149858283692172
    },
    {
      "year": 2008,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 38720012.2546172,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -20.000945246116373,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 2.8450987230934643
    },
    {
      "year": 2009,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 53800767.48636203,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 38.948219160097295,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 5.612042529422778
    },
    {
      "year": 2010,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 49682597.271778725,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -7.654482281553365,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 0.8752336475626121
    },
    {
      "year": 2011,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 43866717.02649041,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -11.706071269731932,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 4.247716090607345
    },
    {
      "year": 2012,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 53561695.28366023,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 22.100988891681084,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.14834187258819798
    },
    {
      "year": 2013,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 59504452.14940363,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 11.09516200760794,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 6.197686672259106
    },
    {
      "year": 2014,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 74708287.85446513,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 25.55075318883324,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 19.42022454443142
    },
    {
      "year": 2015,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 62376671.090334564,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -16.506357083370816,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 5.209743002949718
    },
    {
      "year": 2016,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 39355772.91526684,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -36.906262826576,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -12.87295294791485
    },
    {
      "year": 2017,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 32703504.32054589,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -16.902904204278535,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -24.070856189156686
    },
    {
      "year": 2018,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 48790857.08846667,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 49.19152580787478,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -7.862006318602644
    },
    {
      "year": 2019,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 24399191.798043985,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -49.992286969249534,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -14.73142634339667
    },
    {
      "year": 2020,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 24661225.871732548,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 1.073945710404911,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -8.97931007457775
    },
    {
      "year": 2021,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 33513548.546928547,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 35.895712245767974,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -11.767756429419919
    },
    {
      "year": 2022,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 33167588.788949188,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -1.0322981987267554,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 10.776120892842144
    },
    {
      "year": 2023,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 39863269.43774674,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 20.187420591238237,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 17.359815489357764
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "hs_code": "180400",
      "export_value_usd": 180691971.36551902,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 353.2793569471269,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 75.35015213208476
    }
  ],
  "corridorHistory": [
    {
      "year": 1995,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 50215018991.97828,
      "yoy_growth_pct": null,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 1996,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 49394851496.90449,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -1.6333111318842852,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 1997,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 46056806413.74109,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -6.757880592823707,
      "cagr_3y_pct": null,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 1998,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 49626028073.75679,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 7.749607360858657,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.39251794034023124,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 1999,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 47206509769.180954,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -4.875502631360751,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -1.4991293448605614,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2000,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 45835713808.2607,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -2.903828238145223,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.16027115882861764,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2001,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 42604762236.107765,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -7.048982777204261,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -4.957859292260347,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2002,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 44141084570.34082,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 3.605987344135464,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -2.213169624268674,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2003,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 53555899368.46819,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 21.328915883624113,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 5.325720638973386,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2004,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 63200830552.49784,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 18.009091991289083,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 14.048141680093028,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2005,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 65284007343.74974,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 3.2961224924433763,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 13.934329723811567,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2006,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 72954101045.57265,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 11.74880956899047,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 10.853003482288104,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2007,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 82389323007.01773,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 12.933093309656618,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 9.24025776264914,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2008,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 89738347512.19019,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 8.919874853864851,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 11.187787313115916,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2009,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 71364942431.83072,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -20.47441878497216,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.7314366922692161,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2010,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 80826860579.98723,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 13.258496154739753,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.6361847262921883,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2011,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 93737767276.13977,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 15.973534792157063,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 1.4640466197379354,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2012,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 86010171236.77625,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -8.243844785207,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 6.419602114303324,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2013,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 87801034782.51804,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 2.0821532151258593,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 2.7972053153543674,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2014,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 90095117188.96524,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 2.6128193273913247,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -1.312484279996562,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2015,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 75283254373.75482,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -16.44025034580293,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -4.34312457597128,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2016,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 74580003550.04657,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -0.9341397759146552,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -5.2947063275522455,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2017,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 71770889941.86058,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -3.7665774664397134,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -7.299439731129976,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2018,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 78818724433.50854,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 9.819906785825294,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 1.5415228798415281,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2019,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 74553112245.07387,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -5.411927456442345,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.012020441765092649,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2020,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 66362349494.60401,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -10.986479978924102,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -2.5778281096252686,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2021,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 76407022651.14566,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 15.13610237286489,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -1.030519282585285,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2022,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 77812043642.7267,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 1.8388636840307226,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 1.436365817639551,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2023,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 79906010759.43964,
      "yoy_growth_pct": 2.691057860306767,
      "cagr_3y_pct": 6.386347476678789,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "DEU",
      "export_value_usd": 75320858926.45677,
      "yoy_growth_pct": -5.738181382607943,
      "cagr_3y_pct": -0.47611310591503253,
      "distance_km": 881,
      "capital_distance_km": 881,
      "shares_land_border": 1,
      "shares_official_language": 0,
      "shares_ethnic_language": 0,
      "shared_religion": 0,
      "shared_legal_system": 0,
      "shared_colonial_history": 0,
      "has_fta": 1,
      "rta_coverage_ratio": 2,
      "exporter_is_wto": 1,
      "importer_is_wto": 1,
      "exporter_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_is_eu": 1,
      "importer_gdp_million_usd": 4223116.205968999,
      "importer_gdp_per_capita_usd": 50801.7848771783,
      "importer_population": 83129.288,
      "importer_biz_entry_days": 8,
      "importer_biz_entry_cost_pct": 6.5,
      "exporter_gdp_million_usd": 2937472.757953,
      "exporter_gdp_per_capita_usd": 43518.5378683532,
      "diplomatic_disagreement": 0.05582441136037384,
      "scientific_collaboration": 0.05582441136037384,
      "avg_applied_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_mfn_tariff_pct": 0,
      "avg_preferential_tariff_pct": 0,
      "tariff_advantage_pp": 0
    }
  ],
  "relatedAnomalies": [
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "HKG",
      "hs_code": "854239",
      "market_imports_usd": 58595517135.135826,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 730.8096225142097,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.3706010255375185,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "59.26502563843796",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "China, Hong Kong SAR"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "TWN",
      "hs_code": "854232",
      "market_imports_usd": 40044198303.22224,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 592.5521297352843,
      "anomaly_z_score": 4.525833798310209,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "100",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "Taiwan"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "CHN",
      "hs_code": "870323",
      "market_imports_usd": 23512115502.628315,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 1124.2494044424902,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.703781340668409,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "92.59453351671021",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "CHN"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "USA",
      "hs_code": "854430",
      "market_imports_usd": 14276803352.838371,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 105.8671445731564,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.717147490361592,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "67.9286872590398",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "USA, Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "ARE",
      "hs_code": "271012",
      "market_imports_usd": 14117604327.847712,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 509394.84821762907,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.095459009978249,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "77.38647524945623",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "ARE"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "BRA",
      "hs_code": "270900",
      "market_imports_usd": 8284554074.5442,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 51545904.808862,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.2355803340314404,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "55.88950835078601",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "BRA"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "FRA",
      "hs_code": "870380",
      "market_imports_usd": 7487835105.755303,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 158966.07012607425,
      "anomaly_z_score": 3.8537392303049987,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "96.34348075762496",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "France"
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "exporter_iso3": "FRA",
      "importer_iso3": "USA",
      "hs_code": "210690",
      "market_imports_usd": 7361804659.6877165,
      "momentum_yoy_pct": 31.57372243348666,
      "anomaly_z_score": 2.014771815185312,
      "anomaly_type": "spike",
      "anomaly_severity": "50.369295379632796",
      "new_corridor_signal_type": "",
      "new_corridor_signal_strength": 0,
      "exporter_name": "France",
      "importer_name": "USA, Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands"
    }
  ],
  "links": {
    "html": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/fra-deu-180400",
    "markdown": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/fra-deu-180400/index.md",
    "json": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/fra-deu-180400/index.json",
    "jsonLd": "https://www.yugalinks.com/trade/signal/anomaly/fra-deu-180400/index.ld.json",
    "dataSources": "https://www.yugalinks.com/data-sources",
    "methodology": "https://www.yugalinks.com/methodology"
  },
  "methodology": {
    "summary": "Reported trade observations and calculated indicators are shown separately. An unusual movement is a research prompt, not a causal conclusion or commercial forecast.",
    "url": "https://www.yugalinks.com/methodology"
  },
  "generatedAt": "2026-09-03T09:33:00.107Z",
  "artifactContract": {
    "html": "Full visual page",
    "markdown": "Readable page content and evidence",
    "json": "Complete page data",
    "jsonLd": "Page metadata, FAQ, and provenance"
  }
}